Bangladesh Tour of India 2019 Discussion

[Elite101]

Today I think Ban vs surely beat India and the truth will be exposed

1.We are heavily depended on Rohit and Kohli
2.Now India only wins when they win toss !!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Aalay]

Just poor cricket all around from India. No intent from batsmen apart from Shreyas, fielding was poor with too many easy singles and that all important catch of Mushfiqur being dropped at such an important stage of the match. Apart from Chahal, bowling was pretty average as well. One of the most frustrating matches I have seen in recent while from India.

 

[Elite101]

India has been successfully been defeated by Bangladesh.
This proves without Kohli and Dhoni the team is useless.Rohit is a hitman like comet sometimes hits a big blow like explosion
then silence.The selectors decision to remove Dhoni will now be discussed in news/media i think

As I said before this is proved

1.We are heavily depended on Rohit and Kohli
2.Now India only wins when they win toss !!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[A.P Haux]

Well I didn't expect that! A great win for the tigers and overall a below average performance fron India. That drop from Krunal costed India the game.

 

[Bevab]

Most pleased for Mahmudullah. A perennially underrated player who has completely changed his playing style for the sake of team balance and a much better leadership option than Shakib who I feel was more of an emotional type. Hopefully he is confirmed as the white ball captain for the foreseeable future. Rahim has started this series off well too, interested in seeing in how he plays in the tests now that he has given up the gloves.

India's woes in the T20 format have been an open secret for a while now, their play is awfully close to how England treated ODIs before 2015. A fundamental re-think as to how T20s must be approached is desperately needed as it is futile to depend on one of the top three scoring quickly in the end to compensate for the slower starts and lack of reliable middle order performers. Surely Karthik must be not far away from a recall, given his T20I record over the last two years and an impressive run of form in the Vijay Hazare Trophy as the finisher?

 

[Elite101]

Most pleased for Mahmudullah. A perennially underrated player who has completely changed his playing style for the sake of team balance and a much better leadership option than Shakib who I feel was more of an emotional type. Hopefully he is confirmed as the white ball captain for the foreseeable future. Rahim has started this series off well too, interested in seeing in how he plays in the tests now that he has given up the gloves.

India's woes in the T20 format have been an open secret for a while now, their play is awfully close to how England treated ODIs before 2015. A fundamental re-think as to how T20s must be approached is desperately needed as it is futile to depend on one of the top three scoring quickly in the end to compensate for the slower starts and lack of reliable middle order performers. Surely Karthik must be not far away from a recall, given his T20I record over the last two years and an impressive run of form in the Vijay Hazare Trophy as the finisher?

He should be given a chance since Rishab pant is explosive but defuses before making an impact and that is why selectors ignored him in WC 2019 and they will ignore him from now

 

[NILAYSHAH60]

Surely Karthik must be not far away from a recall, given his T20I record over the last two years and an impressive run of form in the Vijay Hazare Trophy as the finisher?

Do you actually think they have enough brains to give him a chance ? The way they have treated Bhuvi it clearly shows signs that they aren't going back to Dinesh Karthik.

 

[Bevab]

Do you actually think they have enough brains to give him a chance ? The way they have treated Bhuvi it clearly shows signs that they aren't going back to Dinesh Karthik.

I believe there is something about Bhuvi that is being hidden, either related to his fitness (ala Saha) or something more personal. He hasn't played a game in the domestic OD tournament either despite Shastri mentioning that he will mainly be an ODI option from now on. If Karthik is going to be excluded based on his ODI performances, it is a shame as his ability to play unorthodox shots and decent strike rotation could be useful on Aussie grounds next year.

 

[Bevab]

He should be given a chance since Rishab pant is explosive but defuses before making an impact and that is why selectors ignored him in WC 2019 and they will ignore him from now

I don't think Pant deserves to be completely axed, but he should probably be having a long, hard look at himself and get his game sorted out. Does he want to be a Maxwell/AbD type of top order batsman, or a slogger down the order? I would probably have both of them in my strongest Indian lineup.

 

[Aislabie]

Can we have a moment of appreciation for the Bangladeshi selectors for a madcap bit of genius in picking Aminul Islam? Three wickets in 19 List A matches, one first-class wicket at a cost of 116, and two domestic Twenty20s as a specialist batsman was his track record going into this game.

And yet he turned up and looked like he belonged.

Okay, so he's not the finished article. But he threw it up there, gave it a rip and looked for wickets. A truly inspired selection.

 

[Ed Smith]

Fair play to Bangladesh all round tbf. They deserved to win today and looked reasonable comfortable in doing so

 

[Bevab]

Can we have a moment of appreciation for the Bangladeshi selectors for a madcap bit of genius in picking Aminul Islam? Three wickets in 19 List A matches, one first-class wicket at a cost of 116, and two domestic Twenty20s as a specialist batsman was his track record going into this game.

And yet he turned up and looked like he belonged.

Okay, so he's not the finished article. But he threw it up there, gave it a rip and looked for wickets. A truly inspired selection.

Not the first time and certainly not the last time Bangladeshi selectors choose a player with barely any experience for an international game.

 

[Aislabie]

Not the first time and certainly not the last time Bangladeshi selectors choose a player with barely any experience for an international game.

Not at all; but it is quite unusual that they'd pick someone with experience in a completely different role. It'd be picking Joe Denly to bat in a Test top three because he'd improved his part time leggies. Hang on...

 

[LiveLoveABD]

The build up to the 50 over WC was experiments. The build up so far in the T20 format has been experiments.

 

[Elite101]

Update-1-Dhoni vs Rishab Pant

Rishabh Pant hit just 3 fours in a knock of 27 runs
Pant was also involved in the run-out of Shikhar Dhawan

Soon afterward, Pant did convince Rohit Sharma to go for DRS on another instance, when he thought that Soumya Sarkar had nicked one into his gloves. However, the DRS replays showed no spike whatsoever when the ball passed Sarkar's bat as India lost their sole review. This was enough for the numerous social media users to call out Pant.

While some pointed to him lacking wicketkeeping skills, others flayed him for his below-par batting performances so far in his short white-ball career. In turn many started being reminded of veteran wicketkeeper MS Dhoni, whose skills behind the wickets and in front are already the stuff of legends.

You can't make MS Dhoni': Rishabh Pant trolled for poor showing vs Bangladesh

Update-2:Shikhar Dhawan

Legendary India cricketer Sunil Gavaskar feels opener Shikhar Dhawan must rediscover his form soon which made him one of the most potent white-ball batsmen in the world. Dhawan has looked a shadow of himself since recovering from injury which he sustained during 2019 World Cup. In the first T20I against Bangladesh, Dhawan score 41 but he took 42 deliveries to reach there. Also, Dhawan had scores of 36 and 40 against South Africa and struggled to find form during the recently-concluded Vijay Hazare Trophy, where he managed just one fifty in seven outings.Gavaskar stated that people will start to talk if Dhawan is unable to get back to his best in the next two matches against Bangladesh.

“Questions will be raised on Shikhar Dhawan if he doesn’t bat well in the next 2 matches. The team is not going to benefit if you’re scoring 40-45 runs from the same number of balls. He will have to think about this. When players come back after the gap, it does take a lot of time to get back the rhythm,”Gavaskar told Sports Talk

Conclusion and My opinion-No one can easily replace Dhoni and selectors are really mad keeping him away
We should keep him untill he retires atleast for wicket keeping,DRS and other decisions made on field

Guys give your opinion about this