1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Constuctive Criticism

Discussion in 'Graphics Forum' started by Dipak, Jun 17, 2013.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Dipak ICC Board Member

    Dipak
    The Amigos
    Joined:
    Mar 17, 2010
    Location:
    Mumbai, India
    I have noticed here that the comments people get, that is especially newbies, they get vague comments, which are either too harsh or too lenient. Harsh comments discourage the new artist whereas too leniant comments make them feel overconfident even of their poor works. Comments like "Bad Work", "Very Poor" must be avoided , instead suggestions need to be given for the artist to improve. Our goal should be not to criticize, but to help others reaching a good level in Photoshop.


    1. Never use words like "poor" "bad", approach the artist like a friend and not a critic.

    2. Don't try to use advanced terms when you're commenting on a newbies work, just try to explain things from zero level.

    3. Always start you comment with a good point, like "the artwork is really good' and then slowly pick out the negative points.

    4. Try not to use the word copy, if the artwork is inspired by someone else, there is a whole lot difference between copying a work and getting inspired, using the word copy will just make the artist protect himself.

    4. While commenting on the negative points, ensure that the artist is able to comprehend it. Link him to tutorials focusing on his weak point, share a .psd or two.

    5. Lastly end your comment with a good note like "KIU" "you're improving" (if he is :p)

    It takes a lot of practice for constructive criticism, but it's all worth it. A few graphic-artists here for example, when people used to comment good work, his development got stalled, but once he got constructive criticism he came up.

    Regards.

    PS: I'd like a mod to close this thread and sticky it so that it could be read by all.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Jun 17, 2013
    Manish., Ashutosh., Noctis. and 16 others thanked this.
  2. KBC Panel of Selectors

    KBC
    Joined:
    Sep 28, 2006
    Location:
    India
    An Important reminder to new users.

    A lot of you are not getting by these simple instructions.

    There are many one word comments or just smileys being posted in threads. Agree there's nothing wrong with them on a post count disabled forum, but doing that degrades the worth of your posts. Even if you don't have any constructive criticism to give or if you want to appreciate artworks, make sure your opinion is known properly in your posts. Helps you and the others to gather the value of your posts.
     
    Hariharan., AliB, RPHKR and 7 others thanked this.
  3. Simon Keep Austin Weird

    Simon
    The Amigos
    Joined:
    Mar 22, 2011
    Location:
    Austin TX, USA
    A reminder to some of the newer (and also some of the older) members that this still exists and applies to everyone. I've been seeing many posts saying either "good" or "bad" with no real reasoning behind it, and I'm sure all of you can take the time and effort to improve the comments you post on others' threads. I am pleased to see the activity going up in this forum once again, but I feel we also need quality along with quantity in both comments and artworks. Cheers.
     
    Rohith., Hariharan., AliB and 1 other person thanked this.
  4. Simon Keep Austin Weird

    Simon
    The Amigos
    Joined:
    Mar 22, 2011
    Location:
    Austin TX, USA
    Biennial reminder, hahaha. Please take the time to read through this thread, and apply it to your posts. Constructive criticism not only helps the creator of the artwork, but also helps you look at them critically, i.e. understand what makes a good artwork and what doesn't. I understand that a lot of you are new here, but I'm sure you can learn from some of our older members while also taking your own initiative. Let's keep this forum buzzing.. the right way!
     
    AliB said thanks for this.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page