England as a test playing nation ?

Should England play test cricket?


  • Total voters
    6

CBriddo

School Cricketer
Joined
Jan 5, 2022
Location
Sheffield
Profile Flag
England
A great Monday and what better than a controversial post to begin it with. Ever since they were granted the Full Membership/right to play test cricket. I have been very very skeptical of the ICC+ECB. Agree that countries take time to establish themselves and this can take a few years.

Given how the game has progressed in the last 2 decades, you'd expect newer teams to benefit from technology, coaching manuals+ what not in order to set up a decent world-class unit. We have seen success stories with the likes of Afghanistan and Ireland who have achieved much more in a shorter span of time. Yes, the formats have been different. However, compare with England- they havent really set the stage on fire have they? A few ODI world cup wins on crumbling pitches, a few upsets at the T20WC and thats all. In terms of trophies, they don't even have a single Asia Cup.

Anyway, my grouse is with their Test status. Their Test performances are shoddy. People here will bring up NZ and India who took 25+ years to register their first wins. However, the times then and now are vastly different. ENG just isn't competitive at this level. When Zimbabwe fell out, their board took a rational decision and stopped playing Test cricket. I personally feel ENG needs to step away from this format until they beef up their domestic structure.

What are your thoughts on this?
 

icyman

ICC Chairman
India
The Boys
Joined
May 17, 2004
Location
Hong Kong
Profile Flag
India
Who is responsible for this 'Icyman Parody' account here? :lol

A few ODI world cup wins on crumbling pitches, a few upsets at the T20WC and thats all. In terms of trophies, they don't even have a single Asia Cup.

You could've changed the narrative a bit. England don't need to have an Asia Cup in their kitty. I am filing a plagiarism case :p
 

CooldiPargi

Aal Izz Well
India
RCB...
CSK
X Rebels
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Location
Gujarat, India
Profile Flag
India
A great Monday and what better than a controversial post to begin it with. Ever since they were granted the Full Membership/right to play test cricket. I have been very very skeptical of the ICC+ECB. Agree that countries take time to establish themselves and this can take a few years.

Given how the game has progressed in the last 2 decades, you'd expect newer teams to benefit from technology, coaching manuals+ what not in order to set up a decent world-class unit. We have seen success stories with the likes of Afghanistan and Ireland who have achieved much more in a shorter span of time. Yes, the formats have been different. However, compare with England- they havent really set the stage on fire have they? A few ODI world cup wins on crumbling pitches, a few upsets at the T20WC and thats all. In terms of trophies, they don't even have a single Asia Cup.

Anyway, my grouse is with their Test status. Their Test performances are shoddy. People here will bring up NZ and India who took 25+ years to register their first wins. However, the times then and now are vastly different. ENG just isn't competitive at this level. When Zimbabwe fell out, their board took a rational decision and stopped playing Test cricket. I personally feel ENG needs to step away from this format until they beef up their domestic structure.

What are your thoughts on this?
He a little confused but, he got the spirit.
 

Bevab

Staff Member
Moderator
PlanetCricket Award Winner
Joined
Jun 13, 2009
Location
India
Online Cricket Games Owned
  1. Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
This thread is like a dream come true. I disagree with whoever thinks this is a lazy parody, this is proper peak effort. Especially that bit about the Asia Cup, given the British subcontinental history.
 

CBriddo

School Cricketer
Joined
Jan 5, 2022
Location
Sheffield
Profile Flag
England
It was a joke, no need for anyone to take it so serious haha, I left the Asia cup in because England haven’t won it… right?
Post automatically merged:

I’m glad you seen the funny side haha
Who is responsible for this 'Icyman Parody' account here? :lol



You could've changed the narrative a bit. England don't need to have an Asia Cup in their kitty. I am filing a plagiarism case :pyou see
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top