MacGill or Hogg?

[Kerry_OKeeffe]

Who is a better spinner, MacGill or Hogg

Well Hogg is definately a better batsmen but i also think he is a better spinner although he usually dosent take alot of wickets he bowls better then MacGill, he bowls hardly any full tosses or wide's and bowls in the right spot all the time
MacGill gets most of his wickets from full tosses, wides and long hops

 

[Iron-Haggis]

Thats why Hogg plays One dayers and MacGill plays Tests. Hogg is more tidy and MacGill takes more wickets.

 

[squiz]

MacGill would get smashed in ODI's, but i think Hogg could play Test's pretty well

 

[bomber]

I would have Hogg in any team before MacGill.