Dont think there was an argument! He just seems to have given it an "average" rating without even having played the game.
Well if I were to provide an argument, i would come up with the following points :-
1. Default fields are messed up as ever - I saw a field which had mid off, mid on, long off and long on!!! Who on earth conjures up such a field? How can an improved AI help if the default fields are so wrong.
2. I didn't see even one image or video clip featuring a test match which leads me to believe test matches would be as messed as they were in AC09, else Codies would have at least one video featuring a test match. Tests for me is a big thing, and especially in offline mode Test Match is the meat & potatoes of the game.
3. Didn't see any changes in shot animations (shot making or fielding/catching). Batsmen still freeze as soon as they play a shot, and forward defensive looks downright ugly.
4. The game only seems to have one bowling action for all bowlers (fast bowlers at least) and it seems to be based on Shoaib Akhtar's bowling action. So now we have a game which has Stuart Broad bowling with Akhtar's bowling action
These are some of the things that I could see based on released images and videos and I fear that other than the addition of Action Cam, there's nothing much. I look forward to June 4th when PC team will go for a play-test session and I hope to be proven wrong :upray