Draft: Selection: Impossible

Na Maloom Afraad

Man of Tomorrow
Moderator
PlanetCricket Award Winner
The Boys
Joined
Apr 21, 2012
Location
Smallville
:ind: :wkb: Saba Karim, a first-class batting average of 56.66, but a Test batting average of just 15.00, since he only ever appeared in one Test for India.

I reckon that's the 'keeper sorted.

NMA's XI

:eng: :bat: Wally Hardinge
:eng: :ar: Percy Fender
:ind: :wkb: Saba Karim
:eng: :bwl: Derek Shackleton
:eng: :bwl: Douglas Carr
:saf: :bwl: Fred le Roux

@Paranoid Kendroid
 
Last edited:

Bevab

Staff Member
Moderator
PlanetCricket Award Winner
Joined
Jun 13, 2009
Location
India
Online Cricket Games Owned
  1. Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC

Paranoid Kendroid

Staff Member
Moderator
Fantasy Cricket Team
India
AUS..
RCB...
PlanetCricket Award Winner
The Boys
Joined
May 19, 2022
Online Cricket Games Owned
  1. Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
05165.jpg


:ind: :ar: Bal Dani
From espncricinfo - "Few Indian cricketers have had a better all round record in domestic cricket than `Bal' Dani. At the end of a career that spanned more than two decades, Dani finished with figures of 6459 runs (44.54), including 17 centuries and 198 wickets (21.97). In the Ranji Trophy he was simply superb with a tally of 4757 runs (48.05) with 15 hundreds and 145 wickets (19.10) from 78 matches. A sound right hand middle order batsman and a right arm medium pace bowler who could also bowl off and leg breaks, Dani was a tower of strength to the Services team in the national competition for several years with his all round skills, besides being a shrewd captain.

Unfortunately Dani's multitalented skills were not rewarded suitably when it came to selection to the Indian team. He played only one Test, took one wicket (that of Nazar Mohammed for a duck), latched on to a brilliant catch to dismiss Kardar but did not get to bat. He toured Pakistan in 1954-55 without playing a Test. Later he became a member of the National selection committee."

A very capable all-rounder who also served in the Indian Air Force (retd. 1987, highest rank - Air Commodore). Cricinfo has put his bowling style as right-arm fast medium, offbreak and legbreak. Jack of all trades and a lovely addition to my side!


1710588874970.png

No Career Runs XI:
01.
:aus: :bat: Ken Meuleman
03. :saf: :bat: Gerald Bond
04. :afg: :bat: Shahidullah
05. :ind: :ar: Bal Dani
08. :ind: :wk: Vijay Rajindernath
11. :eng: :bwl: Arthur Mold


@Bevab is next
 

Bevab

Staff Member
Moderator
PlanetCricket Award Winner
Joined
Jun 13, 2009
Location
India
Online Cricket Games Owned
  1. Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
giphy.gif

Every mission needs a man with a determined mindset to change the prevailing norm and do things their own way. An individual force of nature that enacts change by their own way so as to speak. But being merely a harbinger of novelty isn't a sign of quality... you need to be good enough to both bring about the change and be pointed to as the new icon in town. Besides, our recruits have all been remarkable and this one shall be no exception.

GettyImages-106528746-scaled-e1605508175475-980x530.jpg


Meet :pak::bwl: Waqar Younis Maitla, arguably the most talented pace bowler ever seen in the last fifty years at his peak. When Waqar was first developing, the rage all around fast bowling in world cricket was who could bowl the meanest and nastiest bouncer to intimidate the batters and draw them into false shots. Any injuries inflicted, accidental or not were just bonuses. The full length ball did exist and was used to great success especially by the Big Bird and early proponents of reverse swing like Nawaz and Imran but nobody had made their modus operandi in test cricket be the fearsome quick yorker and full length ball aimed at the stumps consistently. Waqar did not care for the bouncer tactics of the 80s and instead went straight for the kill (or wicket, in this case) by making full use of his incredible late inswingers to get batters dancing in an entirely different but equally embarrassing manner. The toecrushing yorker was his magnum opus; his finest gift to the cricket world. And if you weren't dimissed by his early swing, he could back to haunt you when the ball was slightly older and reversing all over the place. This relentless pursuit of wickets made him the most feared strike bowler in test history until a certain South African came along but it also made him vulnerable to leaking runs or throwing away momentum. These are however the type of nitpicks that barely make a dent in the records of some of the best out there. If you do want to make a nitpick, he was a terrible off-spin bowler when he did try that out but hey I'm not gonna complain since this is what makes him eligible for my side, we'll most likely never use that particular 'talent' of his.

Waqar's entire career can be summarised by two phases, a first phase where he was the greatest pacer to be bowling in test cricket of his time and perhaps even the greatest ever with a sub-20 average whilst picking up over half of his test wickets to go with nineteen of his twenty-two five wicket hauls. There wasn't a country he hadn't tormented and he ended up picking at least a four wicket haul against each of his opponents. The second, less glamorous phase had him average twenty-eight and pick up the rest of his wickets whilst being slightly more expensive than in the first and with only three five wicket hauls. There were still moments of genius like at Gqeberha where he picked up his last ten wicket haul in a test but it was a pale imitation of his raging first half of career. This was a half equivalent to the likes of Ntini, Srinath, Gough and Caddick back then, handy enough but not quite as legendary as the first half was. Still, that first half of his career was so good that he gets included in every Pakistani XI ever made without restriction and plenty of people have no qualms picking him in their World XI for the sheer hope that he brings the same level of fearsome destruction.

With a generational talent like Waqar that can end games on their own, the best thing you can do is sit back and let them run the show with encouragment and backing like his skipper did. That's what we'll seek to do and we'll let Waqar dish out his favourite yorkers and reverse swing deliveries at will.

:wi: :bat: Viv Richards
:sri: :wkb: Kumar Sangakkara
:wi: :ar: Garry Sobers
:aus: :ar: Keith Miller
:eng: :ar: Ian Botham
:pak: :bwl: Waqar Younis
 

Aislabie

Test Cricket is Best Cricket
Moderator
Ireland
PlanetCricket Award Winner
Joined
Sep 3, 2010
Location
Derbyshire
There’s only room for one Miller in this side. :noway
So this sent me off on a voyage of discovery:
  • :eng: :bat: Audley Miller - never bowled in Test cricket, but a genuine candidate for one of the worst Test players ever. Also has inspired a possible new rule for next time: Test umpires.
  • :aus: :bwl: Colin Miller - someone I definitely expected you to pick in your side before you said that.
  • :nzf: :bat: Evelyn Miller - never bowled in Tests.
  • :eng: :ar: Geoff Miller - this was the closest I could find, but it's definitely just a spinner bowling a quicker ball as opposed to running in and bowling seam-up.
  • :nzf: :bwl: Helen Miller - appears only to have bowled seam-up.
  • :eng: :ar: Keith Miller - already in your team.
  • :nzf: :bat: Lawrie Miller - one of the worst Test careers of all time; only bowled two deliveries and it's lost to time what they were.
  • :wi: :bwl: Nikita Miller - only ever bowled left-arm spin.
  • :wi: :ar: Roy Miller - appears only to have bowled seam-up.
  1. :eng: :bat: Tim Robinson
  2. :eng: :bat: Mark Benson
  3. :eng: :bat: Joe Hardstaff
  4. :eng: :bat: John Hampshire
  5. :eng: :ar: Peter Willey
  6. :aus: :ar: Rod Tucker
  7. :sri: :ar: Kumar Dharmasena
  8. :eng: :wk: Ian Gould
  9. :eng: :bwl: James Lillywhite
  10. :aus: :bwl: Paul Reiffel
  11. :wi: :bwl: Vanburn Holder
Venkat narrowly missed out to Lillywhite; in terms of non-English batters Chris Gaffaney was closest to breaking into the top order. I'm pretty sure I must be missing some players, but it seems like England is the only country that so often sees umpiring as the natural solution to one's playing career coming to an end.

Frank Chester also deserves an honourable mention here: a batting average of 24 and a bowling average of 31 don't look like much, but he played all 55 of his first-class matches as a teenager before his career was ended by WWI.
 
Last edited:

Verified Enigma

PlanetCricket's Sherlock Holmes
PlanetCricket Award Winner
Champions League Winner
Avengers
Joined
Mar 27, 2014
:eng: :ar: Wally Hammond

1710699037075.png

Would be absolutely criminal if I skip Wally Hammond. One of the greatest batsmen to be the part of this game. Destructive, yes. Skillful, yes. Consistent, yes. Can even back up as a fourth pacer. His 336* vs New Zealand was the highest every score in an innings by a batsman at the time, surpassing the GOAT Bradman's 334 knock. If we keep Bradman aside, Hammond will definitely be a strong contender of the next best batsman the game has ever seen.

Barakadi 11:


  1. :ind: :bat: Rahul Dravid
  2. :eng: :ar: Wally Hammond
  3. :saf: :wkb: AB de Villiers

  4. :nzf: :ar: Sir Richard Hadlee
  5. :ind: :ar: Ravichandran Ashwin

  6. :eng: :bwl: Sydney Barnes
@Bigby Wolf
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top