Best ICC game?

[iZeeshan]

So far 6 versions have come out, so which one do you guys prefer?

I have downloaded 2008 and don't like it at all. ICC3 (2007) was ok, but I still think that 2006 Ashes edition still stands as the best.

What do you guys think?

 

[age of the fall]

I love 2008, its a lot better then ICC 3. Only two I've played I'm afraid.

 

[GrahamB]

ICC2 seemed to have the right balance in gameplay, but was restricted to 20 seasons.

ICC2008 is the best of the later versions and a patch could make it the best ever version.

 

[westindies2007]

I love ICC 2008 for International Games.
But it sucks in Domestic game for me, I hardly win any match.

ICC 2006 Rules in Domestic game I win soo much, but that Sucks in International.

So Far ICC 2006 and ICC 2008 rule for me. I don't really like ICC 3, ICC 2002 ,etc

 

[Myrmecophaga]

I loved ICC 2001 2008 is pretty darn good too.

 

[Themer]

ICC 2008 is my favourite bar none.

 

[The_gas]

I like ICC 2008 the best.

 

[Simbazz]

I agree with Gas-sy boy here, ICC08 has the right blend between ICC 06 Ashes, and the ever slowly moving Childish Things graphics! All we need now is ICC to team up with EA and get some decent coverage/commentary! Get player pictures and make the game much more indepth. Sell the game for 40 quid and we're all laughing!

 

[Deleted member 9102]

Edit: Chris Gayle

 

[The_gas]

2008 for me, it's got the gameplay of 2005/6 (with more sixes) with updated graphics and hawkeye. Hawkeye works really well in a game like ICC imo, very good to assess the accuracy of your bowlers over by over and it's good for seeing LBW decisions, however, does anyone else think the umpires are a bit too perfect? I have not yet seen them make one wrong decision...

I hate the bug where the ball seems to bounce off something and go in a different direction though, very annoying, it usually happens on shots that go diagonally up the screen. I hope it is fixed in a patch.

Yeah i have noticed this.

 

[Gunja Dude]

There seems to be a lot of LBW's in this latest version.

ICC08 is good and is better because its newer - but I have had more fun and more memories with ICC06. ICC III wasn't even worth playing a whole season on.... I don't think I ever did.