I ditch players who are 36+ trust me once you get that old in the game you dont make runs anymore.
EDIT: You are really dumb, why not fit Flintoff as an allrounder so he can bowl. Change him for Anderson or Mahmood.
The problem i have is Stuart Law (39 and captain) is the only batsmen not making runs atm, and he bats at 5. So i cant fit young Corbin in. The only reason hes played in CC was because Law has been injured twice.
My line-up is
Loye
Albright (youth)
Hodge
Benning (ave 65 this season)
Law
Flintoff
New (Keeper)
Cork
Mahmood
Anderson
Macgill
I like the security of having the 5th bowler, and cause I have Cork and Flintoff who are exeptional with the bat its a great mix.
Your choice.
I think that with Law out of form, you should get rid of him and bring your young man in.