Can't Field XI

[Spinksy]

From current players, lets make an XI of the worst fielders.

Ill suggest Vaughan and Ntini with Prior keping wicket.

There must be a number of possible Indians but I dont know which are the worst.

EDIT- From posts below

1.
2.
3. Surav Ganguly
4. Mohammad Yousuf
5.
6. Danish Kaneria
7. Dilhara Fernando
8. Makaya Ntini
9. Munaf Patel
10. Stuart MacGill
11. Monty Panesar

Post edited then

 

[GrayNicolls]

I think you mean Matt Prior, not Maddi Prior, and also since when has Michael Vaughan been a terrible fielder?

 

[Jit]

I think you mean Matt Prior, not Maddi Prior, and also since when has Michael Vaughan been a terrible fielder?

lol totally agree with vaughan he has never been a terrible fielder

 

[Spinksy]

Do you guys think that Monty Panesar, Mohammad Yusuf or Surav Ganguly should be added to the side as they are terrible fielders?

 

[Insomniac]

Mohammad Yousuf ran out Sachin Tendulkar once quite brilliantly, so no

Monty, yes. Ganguly, maybe.

Honestly, there's worse fielders than them. Where's Danish Kaneria (improving), Ishant Sharma, and Harbhajhan (I think)

 

[Collingwood50]

Tuffnel?

Matt Prior? he's good, so is Vaughan

 

[Simbazz]

Prior and Vaughan are stupid suggestions, they'd be in my 2nd XI for best, well maybe not Prior, but Virgil definately.

 

[Collingwood50]

Are you a good fielder Spinsky?

 

[Cottager]

ntini's an excellent out-fielder. keeps himself in fine shape.

players to keep in mind: Munaf Patel, Monty Panesar, Ian Bradshaw maybe with his little weak arms. kp if he's playing australia in tests of course

 

[Spinksy]

Are you a good fielder Spinsky?

Nope, I am shite to be honest.

 

[angryangy]

How about Herschelle Gibbs? Generally top class, but he did drop the World Cup...

 

[Griffo]

Tufnell is a shoe in, just youtube and you will find out why. Stuart MacGill was pretty terrible... wasnt even commited to trying to get the ball lol

Dilhara Fernando is pretty awful, he always stuffs up on the boundary rope

Harmison and Tremlett both struggle but its cause they are so tall

Danish Kaneria is one of the most un-coordinated people i have ever seen

Its mostly bowlers because batsmen require more hand eye co-ordination for batting and thats a skill which transfers to the fielding aspect of the game

 

[India2011]

The entire Indian test team except for Gambhir, Dravid, and Dhoni.

As for the other three, Prior definitely, Mohammed Yosuf, and Munaf Patel (who's not in the Indian test side.)

 

[khalek]

Just make a team with all Bangladeshis except Ash, Tamim, Mashrafe and Raqibul

 

[lightbulb]

The entire Indian test team except for Gambhir, Dravid, and Dhoni.

As for the other three, Prior definitely, Mohammed Yosuf, and Munaf Patel (who's not in the Indian test side.)

Prior's seriously improved.