For the first Test against Sri Lanka: Brad Hogg or Stuart MacGill?

[angryangy]

Maybe they wont even go for MacGill because of age?
They probably will go with one of them but in 2 years time they are going to have to find someone else anyway.

But if your next generation is 2-3 years away from being ready, what is the point? You might as well stick with the veteran until they are worth playing.

 

[aussie1st]

Hehe don't know why Cam White is in the other list for spinners. I wouldn't trust his spinners if his life depended on it.

For me Hogg just doesn't look like the guy that is going to get you a wicket in the longer form of the game. There were times where I questioned his wicket taking potential in the ODI game too. He has been going much better lately but still doesn't have that wicket taking feel.

MacGill is the only option at this stage, everyone else is just too inexperienced right now.