MaD
Chairman of Selectors
- Joined
- Dec 19, 2008
- Location
- Sydney, Australia
Entries aren't that bad although they all lack something
PC Graphics Maker Championship Season 8 | Final Round - R#10 Results + Season Summary!
- Thread starter RUDI
- Start date
- Status
Varun
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2009
- Location
- Delhi, India
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
Entry 5,7,12 look good, entry 2's good too.
iridescentt
Panel of Selectors
- Joined
- Apr 6, 2009
- Location
- Sydney, Australia
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
To be quite blunt. Its going to be hard judging them this week. Not because of the fact that there so good, but because none of them really 'stand out' from the pack.
treva
ICC Chairman
Entry 12's avatar is my favourite, mainly because of the image used. Entry 5 and 7 have the best sigs, with 7 probably just edging it as my favourite.
Pranav
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2007
- Location
- New Delhi, India
I thought I'll share my views regarding the entries.
Entry 1 : I thought the filmstrip idea always works, but you've changed my thinking. It looks really bad. The text doesn't suit the style either. The avatar is below average as well.
Entry 2 : Nice avatar. The sig is not bad but isn't good either. It's good that you are trying to add effects. Though, it seems a bit untidy here. The render's size should be reduced as well. A good try.
Entry 3 : I am being blunt, but this is the worst entry of the week. Those lines are pathetic. The avatar sucks as well. I like the ball idea, but a softball in cricket?
Entry 4 : Both the avatar and the signature could have been a lot better if you would have worked a bit on the text. Sorry to say but the avatar seems to have very less work on it. The sig looks good imo. Nice colouring. Though, I don't regard this entry as one of the contenders to win this week.
Entry 5 : Definitely one of the contenders for this week. I like the avatar a lot. Nice positioning and effects added to it. This sig is good as well. Though, I think it's a bit simple and the text needs some work.
Entry 6 : Nice stuff here. The avatar can be a bit better. The sig looks good, but again the text seems to be simple. Nice entry, though it could have been better.
Entry 7 : As much as I like the sig, I dislike the avatar. The avatar needs some heavy amount of work. The light source doesn't good look good at all. The colours don't work for me either. The sig look very good. I like the text and the classic touch you've added to it. Though, I still feel it doesn't have a wow factor to it.
Entry 8 : The avatar is decent and the sig is pathetic. Both of them need huge amount of work. For God's sake stop using that style over and over again. It's becoming monotonous. The text looks looks very bad.
Entry 9 : The avatar is OK. Though, I think it's a bit blurred and thus LQ as well. The sig seems to very random. A scenery in the background and few textures placed here and there. The text looks bad. It's not positioned well and I am not a fan of the outer glow you have added to it.
Entry 10 : Nice avatar. I like the position and colouring in it. Sig seems to be random. You should have probably worked with a bigger canvas. Though, I regard it as an above average entry.
Entry 11 : One of my favorites. I like both the sig and avatar. Though, I think the text in the avatar could have been improved. The right side in the sig looks flawless. The left side could have been improved imo. I really like the dimensions you've chosen for the sig. I like the text in the sig.
Entry 12 : Really good avatar. The stock you've taken works wonders here. Though I don't like the sig at all. It seems very less work has gone into it. A background with the render pasted over it, plus some phtotofilters. I'm not a fan of the text either.
Entry 13 : Again, very nice avatar. I like everything about it. The sig is decent as well. I really like the left side of the sig. The right side needs improvement though. The text is OK, but needs to be positioned better.
Entry 14 : Both the avatar and sig are over sharpened and thus very low quality. It's probably the worst set after the Anil Kumble one. The text is pathetic as well.
I hope these comments help to improve some of you guys.
Entry 1 : I thought the filmstrip idea always works, but you've changed my thinking. It looks really bad. The text doesn't suit the style either. The avatar is below average as well.
Entry 2 : Nice avatar. The sig is not bad but isn't good either. It's good that you are trying to add effects. Though, it seems a bit untidy here. The render's size should be reduced as well. A good try.
Entry 3 : I am being blunt, but this is the worst entry of the week. Those lines are pathetic. The avatar sucks as well. I like the ball idea, but a softball in cricket?
Entry 4 : Both the avatar and the signature could have been a lot better if you would have worked a bit on the text. Sorry to say but the avatar seems to have very less work on it. The sig looks good imo. Nice colouring. Though, I don't regard this entry as one of the contenders to win this week.
Entry 5 : Definitely one of the contenders for this week. I like the avatar a lot. Nice positioning and effects added to it. This sig is good as well. Though, I think it's a bit simple and the text needs some work.
Entry 6 : Nice stuff here. The avatar can be a bit better. The sig looks good, but again the text seems to be simple. Nice entry, though it could have been better.
Entry 7 : As much as I like the sig, I dislike the avatar. The avatar needs some heavy amount of work. The light source doesn't good look good at all. The colours don't work for me either. The sig look very good. I like the text and the classic touch you've added to it. Though, I still feel it doesn't have a wow factor to it.
Entry 8 : The avatar is decent and the sig is pathetic. Both of them need huge amount of work. For God's sake stop using that style over and over again. It's becoming monotonous. The text looks looks very bad.
Entry 9 : The avatar is OK. Though, I think it's a bit blurred and thus LQ as well. The sig seems to very random. A scenery in the background and few textures placed here and there. The text looks bad. It's not positioned well and I am not a fan of the outer glow you have added to it.
Entry 10 : Nice avatar. I like the position and colouring in it. Sig seems to be random. You should have probably worked with a bigger canvas. Though, I regard it as an above average entry.
Entry 11 : One of my favorites. I like both the sig and avatar. Though, I think the text in the avatar could have been improved. The right side in the sig looks flawless. The left side could have been improved imo. I really like the dimensions you've chosen for the sig. I like the text in the sig.
Entry 12 : Really good avatar. The stock you've taken works wonders here. Though I don't like the sig at all. It seems very less work has gone into it. A background with the render pasted over it, plus some phtotofilters. I'm not a fan of the text either.
Entry 13 : Again, very nice avatar. I like everything about it. The sig is decent as well. I really like the left side of the sig. The right side needs improvement though. The text is OK, but needs to be positioned better.
Entry 14 : Both the avatar and sig are over sharpened and thus very low quality. It's probably the worst set after the Anil Kumble one. The text is pathetic as well.
I hope these comments help to improve some of you guys.
Last edited:
drainpipe32
Chairman of Selectors
- Joined
- Sep 24, 2008
- Online Cricket Games Owned
Comprehensive. I think that one's got some potential, but yeah, the lines ruin it.
MattW
Administrator
I'd suggest not using one that includes your username in the url.
drainpipe32
Chairman of Selectors
- Joined
- Sep 24, 2008
- Online Cricket Games Owned
That's a pree good point.
I'll make sure of that next time.
I'll make sure of that next time.
Pranav
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2007
- Location
- New Delhi, India
Added to the first post.
AbhishekS
Chairman of Selectors
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2008
- Location
- Mumbai, India
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
drainpipe32
Chairman of Selectors
- Joined
- Sep 24, 2008
- Online Cricket Games Owned
When will we see the results?
Pranav
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2007
- Location
- New Delhi, India
I've got the ratings from Matt, Skrillex_x and Leggie. Nick and Neo haven't come online from a long time.
So, I'll probably be declaring them today.
So, I'll probably be declaring them today.
- Status
