It's certainly the best AFL game graphics and presentation wise, although sometimes it feels a bit clustered and a bit confusing. This could just be due to me not really playing it for very long, but I was confused on where to go, and what to do.. who to sign, how to do it.
The gameplay wasn't great either. The big match screen is nice, but it feels very weird. Commentary is confusing, and a lack of player names in the match engine is also strange.
You know what? Premiership Coach is very modern, well presented and hugely detailed.. but, I think I prefer the simplicity yet brilliance of Footy Fanatic...