MS Dhoni-Hack or Star?

[woodywiss sa sa]

Just because a bowler may well have completely ripped through every team once doesn't mean their amazing in my eyes. They have to do it consistantly something Lee definatly hasn't done.

 

[Leicester Fox]

i'd rather face warne than lee

 

[slimmshady]

If dhoni is a overated keeper then what is kamran akmal? All you pakistani fans out there, do you remember akmal in the series against england? yeah, i thought saw. Then all you pakistanis try to critisize dhoni, what i say is you keep to your keeper and we'll keep to ours. Also keeping to harbhajan singh and anil kumble is not a easy thing to do, especially when they bowl their quicker deliveries. So you guys can't say bull.

 

[Gunner786]

If dhoni is a overated keeper then what is kamran akmal? All you pakistani fans out there, do you remember akmal in the series against england? yeah, i thought saw. Then all you pakistanis try to critisize dhoni, what i say is you keep to your keeper and we'll keep to ours. Also keeping to harbhajan singh and anil kumble is not a easy thing to do, especially when they bowl their quicker deliveries. So you guys can't say bull.

did you see dhoni against england "IN INDIA"?
akmal scored 154 vs england "AT HOME"
dhoni failed on all fronts "AT HOME"
akmal saved his team from 39-6 and hit 113 at number 8 with just the tail for company
And no pakistani even thinks about comparing Akmal and Dhoni
its a waste of time cos its too much in akmals favour

 

[slimmshady]

gambino you're dreaming mate, who scored 183* off 145 balls against Sri Lanka at Jaipur on 31 October 2005 with 10 sixes, the highest score for a wicket keeper. Oh, thats a real tough one....

maybe it could be akmal....or maybe NOT!!!!

 

[Gunner786]

gambino you're dreaming mate, who scored 183* off 145 balls against Sri Lanka at Jaipur on 31 October 2005 with 10 sixes, the highest score for a wicket keeper. Oh, thats a real tough one....

maybe it could be akmal....or maybe NOT!!!!

on the flattest tracks you could ever have?

i dont wanna get into a discussion about dhoni so please dont bore me

 

[kodos]

on the flattest tracks you could ever have?

i dont wanna get into a discussion about dhoni so please dont bore me

I'd actually say the world record track at Johannesburg was the flattest tracks ever.

If you don't want to engage in a discussion about Dhoni then why are you posting in this thread, the title specifically says "Dhoni" not Akmal.

 

[Gunner786]

I'd actually say the world record track at Johannesburg was the flattest tracks ever.

If you don't want to engage in a discussion about Dhoni then why are you posting in this thread, the title specifically says "Dhoni" not Akmal.

like i said i dont wanna discuss him,
it bores me,
good bye

 

[Cricket_god]

like i said i dont wanna discuss him,
it bores me,
good bye

Why did you say some stupid things then first you say dhoni scored on flat tracks but i believe in pakistan they have green tops oh no i remember they play on flattest of the flat tracks.Dhoni may not be as talented as any street
wicket keeper according to all of you.
but players are judjed by there performances not potential dhoni or talent he has done well so guys who criticize him because a new indian wicket keeper has come in 1 match or all those who say he is the worst with the gloves remember
no body starts as great but the guys who learn from their mistake are who succeed in any form of life.He might have got out trying to slog udal in india but he learned and in a similar situation tried to play defensively in south africa.i do not judge players by 1-2 seasons its just how consistent they are it matters so wait and watch.

 

[Gunner786]

Why did you say some stupid things then first you say dhoni scored on flat tracks but i believe in pakistan they have green tops oh no i remember they play on flattest of the flat tracks.Dhoni may not be as talented as any street
wicket keeper according to all of you.
but players are judjed by there performances not potential dhoni or talent he has done well so guys who criticize him because a new indian wicket keeper has come in 1 match or all those who say he is the worst with the gloves remember
no body starts as great but the guys who learn from their mistake are who succeed in any form of life.He might have got out trying to slog udal in india but he learned and in a similar situation tried to play defensively in south africa.i do not judge players by 1-2 seasons its just how consistent they are it matters so wait and watch.

you guys are going over the top
noone was talking about dhoni,
we were comparing akmals recent form stats with other keepers in the world
then one of you starts harking on about stop criticizing dhoni

you guys need to get over dhoni or read other posts before posting a over the top reply

 

[Cricket_god]

you guys are going over the top
noone was talking about dhoni,
we were comparing akmals recent form stats with other keepers in the world
then one of you starts harking on about stop criticizing dhoni

you guys need to get over dhoni or read other posts before posting a over the top reply

Its the topic of the thread you are in the wrong thread mate.

 

[andrew_nixon]

This thread is about MS Dhoni. If you don't want to talk about him, don't post here.

 

[Gunner786]

Its the topic of the thread you are in the wrong thread mate.

there was already discussion about other keepers so i joined in,
i didnt start the subject of other keepers stats