RoboRocks's Signature making Competition

[RoboRocks]

Next sig is Daniel Vettori.

 

[arghasen]

Are you guys sure you wont run away like that again judges? Lol
Then we shall post the sigs.

 

[usy]

Robo, sorry I've really been busy, sorry.

 

[RoboRocks]

You and Virendar Sehwag have got to post your results usy or we have to replace you both, First offical warning for you two.

 

[gaurav_indian]

Its a good competition.But as usual not many participants in it.

 

[arghasen]

Here is my entry.

Daniel Vettori

 

[RabbleRouser]

Here's mine

 

[RoboRocks]

Ok guys judging is today.
Will post mine after a well deserved rest.

 

[surendar]

we will do Robo!!!!

 

[RoboRocks]

arghasen

Colour:15 The colour is pretty suitable to Daniel Vettori as a New Zelander
Font:12 The two differnt fonts don't work for him really.
Images 18 I like the images, particualy the transparent one.
Design 9 I think the New Zeland falg should be removed it makes the pictures look a bit strange.

Total 54 A decent score a few improvements must be made, a pretty average sig.

RabbleRouser

Colour 20 Brilliant Colour effect, goes well with both text and images.
Font: 16 I like the font style but could be made a bit bigger.
Images 19 lovely images as well, nice use of transparacy to see the background.
Design 20 Just a brilliant design goes well with everything and is very eyecatching and relevent.

Total 75 A brilliant sig alround just one improvment, make the text a bit bigger and you have a perfect sig.

 

[surendar]

Judgement

First of all, Its a excellent effort by both Argha and RabbleRouser !!!! Good work!!!

Color :

Argha: Good Selection of the color!!! (17/20)
RabbleRouser : Same color used...So good color selection.(17/20)

Font :

Argha: Improvements needed...For eg : the letter 'V' of "Vettori" appears near the mouth tht looks little odd..Though good use of trnsparency...Could have been better if that letter would have appeared near his shirt rather than the face!!!!!! Big Font is good but slight improvement in style needed!!!! Another thing is that it woild have looked excellent if the name would have appeared between two Vettori's!!!! But good effort overall!!!

(15/20)

RabbleRouser : I like the style u have used it...But there must be improvement in size!!! i.e big font would have looked better!!!

But one thing is very very odd...." He is better than Giles ".... well first of all,this sig is about Vettori and only vettrori...So COMPARISONS are not nice....Eventhough Vettori may be better than Giles but this sig makes Vettori higher and Giles lower!!! Its not necessary to underestimate Giles ...This may be ur personal view...Its not nice to include in the competition....

This would have been much better if "Vettori,The Great spinner" or something like that as it doesnt tells low about anybody...

What i like to say is... U have used your font in brilliant way but The comparison has spoiled ths sig!!!!!

Even I prefer Vettori than Giles..but this is personal opinion...So plz dont include in public competitions .....

(10/20)


Images :



Argha : Excellent.... (19/20)
RabbleRouser : Excellent !!! (19/20)


Design :

Argha : I think NZ flag makes a odd look...But good design except that flag....
Note this(sig) again...The flag is on the half of Vettori's face....Argha, i tell u onething...U do good designs but u are keeping the things in different places.... tht too u like face very much i suppose !!! So i hope u keep the things in right places so tht it matches the design overall
(10/20)

RabbleRouser : Great Design especially the pattern u have used is excellent i.e white dots in the blue background looks great... (19/20)


Total :


Argha : 61

RabbleRouser : 65

To Argha : Good effort but need to keep the things in right place...Dont disturb the face which is important

To RabbleRouser : Great effort but without comparison, it would have reached around 90!!! Anyways Congrads!!!!

 

[RoboRocks]

Guys Usy has resigned as a judge, I need someone to take his place.
Plus everyone else please judge.

 

[RoboRocks]

Since the other judges don't look like posting.
I'l do mine and surendar's ratings.
Which means RabbleRouser has won.
Reps for u!!
EDIT: I can't give you reps becuase I have to spread them around sorry mate.

 

[surendar]

Congrads RabbleRouser!!!!

 

[usy]

RoboRocks - How about I make some Sigs instead of judging? next time around, please?