To manual appeal or not to manual appeal?

[Jaztheman]

On cricket 07, if it goes to third umpire before the replay even starts the traffic like lights either lights up red or green before the replay so try not to have that.

 

[zimrahil]

as mentioned above, i had real problems doing picture in picture (PIP) -multiple camera views slows it right down on an average machine.

That's a real shame, cos as everyone knows, that would be the ideal scenario for lbw shouts - its allows a potential run to be taken but at the same time there is suspense as you are waiting for the decision

How about a PIP where the small picture is simply a screen with a large '?' (or whatever) and eventually (bit like third umpire decisions in real life) an 'OUT' or 'NOT OUT' is displayed on screen.

Hence no real animation or resource hit (hopefully)

Anyways, just a thought

 

[Deleted member 9102]

Edit: Chris Gayle

 

[MasterBlaster76]

Definitely include Manual appeal. Also include a better more realistic Out/Not out videoscreen. Not just a poxy red and green light! Also, in ODIs, let's have the Jaws music (if not copyright problem) while waiting for umpire's decision.

 

[andy82]

Also, in ODIs, let's have the Jaws music (if not copyright problem) while waiting for umpire's decision.

It won't be allowed as you said about the copyright, however, I'm certain that it can be added via patch or manually done