GNsux said:
or Sini?a Mihajlović. I think he has the highest conversion rate in the world.
If you're going with players that have retired (I think he's retired hasn't he, if not why not
)
Then I would go for Zico, he had a phenomenal record in Brazil, scored something like 70%, whenever they got a free kick the crowd would cheer as though they had just won a penalty.
edit - for the lazy people who don't read the rest of a thread, I have already said Juninho from present day