Cricket Revolution Official Review

MattW

Administrator
Admin
Big Ant
PlanetCricket Award Winner
Melbourne Stars
Joined
Jan 12, 2006
Location
Melbourne, Australia
Profile Flag
Australia
Much delayed, but perhaps there's still some benefit to posting up an official review for CR:

Developed by new developer Mindstorm Studios, Cricket Revolution marks one of the only serious attempts to break into the 3D cricket simulation market in recent years, one dominated by Codemasters and still shadowed by EA Sports. However the overwhelming impression of Cricket Revolution is a game that doesn't know what it is meant to be and results in something that few will find appealing.

67656d1269173790-cricket-revolution-official-review-stadium.jpg

An overview of one of the stadiums in Cricket Revolution

When first word of the game got out, the descriptions were of an awful sounding arcade experience; however shortly before release we got claims of 'realistic gameplay'. The change though is not one that can just be made with a few tweaks, it is fundamental to the approach developers take to creating a game. As such, the game is near fatally flawed.

There is a huge screen listing nearly every country where someone owns a cricket bat, however this apparent large choice of teams is misleading. You have ten main teams that are actually full of players and they are the only ten that the computer can play as. Beyond this, even if you do create squads for these other teams, they all play in a generic Cricket Revolution kit. However, there seems potential for rather big patches to add in things like domestic cricket sides if someone were to put the time in. Another problem with squads is that there are only 11 players in them, which means there's a key element lacking in the tournament modes. There is a well rounded choice of modes, but it lacks the option for test matches. The large choice of empty teams brings up Cricket Revolution's each way bet on mods, the game is fairly editable, but only to a point. If Cricket Revolution wants customisation as a strong point, they need play PES and copy and paste a Master League in.

67665d1269173911-cricket-revolution-official-review-teams.jpg

The teams listing

For multiplayer there is a LAN and an Internet option, though the game suffers from very low numbers of players and after several attempts I was unable to set up a game. There are a handful of fictitious stadiums that have no relation to any real world ones, but look somewhat shiny. The graphics are okay at best, you get some oddities in animation like having batsmen turn and stay in a ready position after each run (with occasional follow throughs when it is a close runout), but the only major issues are the low quality of the graphics and the relatively high demands they make of my graphics card. This is likely just a lack of thorough optimisation, so may well be improved as time goes on, Cricket Revolution has been patched numerous times since release, though no significant changes are apparent.

67661d1269173853-cricket-revolution-official-review-rubberducky.jpg


The realistic gameplay takes an immediate hit when you first go out to bat. First off you will be confronted by the fact that the batsman sees the pitch of the ball before it leaves the bowlers hand and then must move across the crease to be in the right line to play the desired shot. These two factors ruin batting and that's before you get to the ill thought-through control scheme, which involves having to pick shots based on about 15 combinations of arrow key presses, like doing combos in a fighting game.

67663d1269173878-cricket-revolution-official-review-footwork1.jpg


These button presses are made much more difficult by the complete lack of feedback as to correct timing, even the information given in the nets about timing is minimal, yet out in the middle you are expected to time everything perfectly and know the correct position to be in to play the shot. In my experience of the game, this means that going for anything other than a single to a fielder isn't worth the risk.

67664d1269173890-cricket-revolution-official-review-footwork2.jpg


A complete lack of difficulty curve compounds this, with no discernable difference between easy and hard, there is no forgiveness to learn the controls. You basically either get it or you don't and like me, if you can't get it right you will end up frustrated. The CPU will smash you around and bowl perfectly as you struggle to connect your shots.

As a break from the batting, the bowling controls are far improved, the 'bowling gadget' is a quite innovative and well designed control. However it doesn't give quite enough control, in batting you have all the shots to choose from, but in bowling you only decide the seam position and speed of the delivery.

67657d1269173810-cricket-revolution-official-review-bowlinggadget.jpg

The Bowling Gadget

The only break from this comes when your bowler fills an adrenaline meter, unfortunately this then brings out one of the most arcadey and unrealistic parts of the game. The ball can create a fire trail! These come from each bowler's specific special deliveries, including things like the 'toe-crusher' or more mundane things like a slower ball. The game gives no real indication what these are to you besides on the bowler selection menu, for a game so dependent on getting controls right, it doesn't go out of its way to tell you them. Cricket 07 and Ashes Cricket 09 are both far better in giving feedback to the player in what to press and what is available to the bowler.

67659d1269173833-cricket-revolution-official-review-fireball.jpg

67660d1269173842-cricket-revolution-official-review-fireball2.jpg


Fielding is all automatic, besides choosing the end to which fielders throw to. It is more accurate than it should be, with perfect throws and hitting the stumps from the boundary happening most times. However as someone who doesn't like fielding in cricket games, it is nice for other people to do it.

For a game that tries to be arcade-like, it is completely devoid of fun thanks to a horrible control scheme and steep difficulty curve. As a realistic cricket simulation, it fails thanks to gimmicks in bowling and the huge issues with footwork when batting.

Besides many fundamental flaws, there are a lot of missing touches. The lack of replays mean you are left wondering how you got out very frequently and the hawkeye-esque ball tracking for LBWs doesn't show the full picture either. The lack of controller support compounds the problem of poor controls and once you've gotten through the over, you need to grab the mouse to navigate the menus. The lack of commentary adds to a lacking atmosphere, with only the same few crowd noises to keep the silence away.

67658d1269173820-cricket-revolution-official-review-doteye.jpg


Cricket Revolution set out to be just that, but there was a huge lack of decisiveness. The game tried to be different, but forgot there was a good reason so many cricket games have had very similar control schemes. It could have set out a great niche by having a strong online component, but despite the low price, the game just isn't good enough to get people coming back to play more. I'm sure many left frustrated and the ones remaining are those who were able to master the controls. PlanetCricket members who were able to master the controls have noticed how the difficulty isn't there anymore, it is really poor for a game to rely on being hard to play to create overall difficulty.

67662d1269173863-cricket-revolution-official-review-therevolutioncontainszombies.jpg


Something I always say about difficulty levels on cricket games is that they focus too much on shortening timing windows instead of just making AI smarter. The AI should be learning from your gameplay, it should learn from how opponents react to you online. The game should just try to keep you on that point of knowing you're in there with a chance, but not being able to topple all the batsmen. Levels of difficulty are an outdated concept, a cricket game that is truly adaptive is the only one that would be able to cope with the wild changes between what casual gamers want and what the traditionalists want. The cricket game that can get this right will be able to be forgiven for a lot.

But I digress. Cricket Revolution has potential, it is great to have new entrants in the cricket games market, but they need to look at what the other games are doing right. When people think of their perfect games, they inevitably say they want various parts out of various games (and ideally a lot of stuff out of football games). When you think of Cricket Revolution, there is very little you would want other games to emulate.

As for scores,
Gameplay - 5
Graphics - 4
Patchability - 7
Longevity - 6

Overall - 5/10 - It's a foundation to build from, but they must correct some fundamental issues before the game can improve.
 

Attachments

  • stadium.jpg
    stadium.jpg
    33.9 KB · Views: 611
  • bowlinggadget.jpg
    bowlinggadget.jpg
    11.9 KB · Views: 582
  • doteye.jpg
    doteye.jpg
    39.8 KB · Views: 579
  • fireball.jpg
    fireball.jpg
    47.3 KB · Views: 583
  • fireball2.jpg
    fireball2.jpg
    35.9 KB · Views: 574
  • rubberducky.jpg
    rubberducky.jpg
    60.1 KB · Views: 587
  • therevolutioncontainszombies.jpg
    therevolutioncontainszombies.jpg
    62.8 KB · Views: 581
  • footwork1.jpg
    footwork1.jpg
    44.1 KB · Views: 585
  • footwork2.jpg
    footwork2.jpg
    45 KB · Views: 584
  • teams.jpg
    teams.jpg
    63.2 KB · Views: 595

sachin_rocks

International Cricketer
Joined
Feb 27, 2010
Online Cricket Games Owned
it is a crap game even more than ashes 2009 i
ts online is also crap some people just say it has better gameplay just do so by reading comments not by thier own experience
and
good review although a little late
it has a lower score in all sections compared to ashes cricket 2009 so i now can officialy state that cricket revolution is crap and ashes is way better:p
 
D

Dutch

Guest
Thanks for the review Matt. I agree with you on most points. I would still rate CR above Ashes 09 in terms of overall enjoyment. That is of course very personal. It is such a shame that no one cricket game can get it all right. If we could mix the qualities each game has together we would be really getting there. Do you know if Mindstorm are planning a second version??
 
P

pcfan123

Guest
Review pretty much sums up my experience.

Another sad note about this game is that since it was released on PC only it was a financial failure. From what I have heard it sold less than 4k copies and did not even break even. Hopefully they will learn from Codies and give us a console option for the next edition. That alone will double or triple sales.
 
P

pcfan123

Guest
Nope no solid source just that less than 2000 people bought it on Steam and some PC members who know Mindstorm said that the total sales totalled between $50-100k.
 

MattW

Administrator
Admin
Big Ant
PlanetCricket Award Winner
Melbourne Stars
Joined
Jan 12, 2006
Location
Melbourne, Australia
Profile Flag
Australia
Do you know if Mindstorm are planning a second version??
There's a post on Cricket Gaming saying there is and that it will be fully 'next gen'. So from that I'll suggest probably not :p.
 
D

Dutch

Guest
There's a post on Cricket Gaming saying there is and that it will be fully 'next gen'. So from that I'll suggest probably not :p.


Lol....and second gen will be already fifth gen by then!
 

Hitterman

International Coach
Joined
Dec 28, 2006
Location
India
Online Cricket Games Owned
There's a post on Cricket Gaming saying there is and that it will be fully 'next gen'. So from that I'll suggest probably not :p.
LOL at least thats not like some imaginative features of ICC cricket 09:p

Hitterman added 1 Minutes and 20 Seconds later...

Do you know if Mindstorm are planning a second version??
See you can only speculate because the post saying it's a next gen is from the Q/A and Q/A is never true :p
 

drainpipe32

Chairman of Selectors
Joined
Sep 24, 2008
Online Cricket Games Owned
I first played this game on Saturday with zero expectations and loved it! Thoroughly enjoyed it, wasn't looking for any details so didn't find any flaws :)

Apparently Mindstorm are planning a sequel (My sources at Wikipedia tell me so)
 
D

Dutch

Guest
I first played this game on Saturday with zero expectations and loved it! Thoroughly enjoyed it, wasn't looking for any details so didn't find any flaws :)

Apparently Mindstorm are planning a sequel (My sources at Wikipedia tell me so)


It can be a great little game to play: online is a bit of a disaster to be honest: nobody there and it is a slogfest.
 
P

pcfan123

Guest
I first played this game on Saturday with zero expectations and loved it! Thoroughly enjoyed it, wasn't looking for any details so didn't find any flaws :)

Apparently Mindstorm are planning a sequel (My sources at Wikipedia tell me so)

Come back after you have played it for a few weeks. Sounds like the novelty has not worn off yet.
 

thedon5

Panel of Selectors
Joined
Nov 1, 2009
Location
New Zealand
Online Cricket Games Owned
It's OK, it kept me occupied for a month. I think there is potential, but no, there won't be a second version if it failed so badly. I think if they can correct just some of the huge errors, they may be able to serve up a decent game.

I think there were 3000-5000 sales. This is what I can tell from the amount of registered users.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top