When Sohum asked me for ideas about this a few days ago, I had a good look through those threads and I'm starting to see how flawed the system was. The team was not balanced at all and there was no rhyme or reason for the ratings. If people want to go with an NBA team of PC members, so here's what I'm proposing:
- First five signups will be starters, hence will have a higher rating
- Sixth signup will be the sixth man
- Next four signups will be role players
- The last 2 bench players and other roster spots should go to actual scrubs from the NBA so there are no PC members that are always on the bench
Now the starting 5 will always have immense pressure on them to perform or they could see less and less minutes or eventually be benched, the sixth man can see upward or downward mobility based on his performance but will see the least change (based on position of course), and the role players can always hope for more minutes or even starting roles in case of injuries/bad numbers from starters.
I think this is the most fair and realistic way of doing things.
Thoughts?