I got the game yesterday but i've only played the opening county championship match and a one day game and so far,so good!
It depends if you liked 2002 - i did,and this seems basically an update of the database and thats it (still can't understand why Keith Parsons of Somerset is STILL not an all-rounder).
Its got the 20/20 tournament so that will be interesting because i always found it hard to play batsmen attacking sensibly.
If you're a mad fan of 2002 then i'd say get it otherwise stick to Brian Lara - personally i think Brian Lara has come on leaps and bounds since the last game but Cricket Captain hasn't.