End Game Friends and Enemies and Enemies and That Other Guy - Sodium (Goon) wins!!!

[Gaurav_7]

Yes we might be partners being VT?

So you're basically saying you two are the masons?

 

[Neo 7]

Guys just tell me one thing. If I had been a Mafia or a Werewolf, why would I be going for not lynching anyone on Day 1?

There's the crux of Day 1 !
Easy . If you had been a mafia or werewolf , why would you lynch someone when you can easily kill at night ?

Hoot him to death . Just 2 votes .

 

[Neo 7]

Waiting for that spicy question ahead .

 

[Perfect Square]

We might have only a few hours left. Before @RUDI can end this Day. So be sensible

 

[RUDI]

Lynch count Day 1: With 11 players alive, it takes 6 votes to reach a majority.

AK: 1(AliB)
Sodium: 1 (AK)
Yash.:4 (Naman/Rebel/FP/CK)
No votes: 5 (Sodium/PS/surendar/Villain/Yash)

 

[Yash.]

There's the crux of Day 1 !
Easy . If you had been a mafia or werewolf , why would you lynch someone when you can easily kill at night

Do you know? 2 > 1. If I was a mafia, I would have lynched one now, then killed someone at night. Would have been more chance of winning.

 

[Targaryen]

I haven't got any answer from @Naman Thakur even though he has posted and replied to other people after my post. That's weird!

Two kills are better than 3. If there is anything solid, I can vote against Yash. Would like to know the final word from him. I'm currently happy with 'No Lynch'.

I have my doubts on FP, Naman, Rebel and Yash.

 

[Gaurav_7]

What are your doubts on me?

 

[Targaryen]

What are your doubts on me?

Possible partner to FP since you are agreeing to a guy who himself looks scummy. It would be great if others also give their thoughts on this too.

 

[Perfect Square]

Okay so after noticing. Rebel has been quite when the thread was hot. He's one of the experienced player in Mafia games. So why still Rebel hasn't found FP sus.? Rebel is one of those few who wasn't brought up in the lime light.

FOS: Rebel and FP

 

[Gaurav_7]

I am agreeing with him? I think I just shared some thoughts of his on Ali and Ali did look suspicious. And ever since Ali has soft hinted about something I seriously have stopped suspecting him for now. Now I am really vary of Surender. He has been too silent for my liking and seems like an anti town getting under the radar.

 

[CerealKiller]

And there is a reason for it. I don’t believe that I must declare a person mafia if I find his posts a lil’ sus. I think we must not jump to declarations, before getting enough evidence.

You seriously haven't found anyone "a little sus" yet? If we keep waiting for some clue to magically appear, we'll end up without a lynch, and Mafia and Werewolves will kill two people at night. Two kills are guaranteed (unless they manage to hit each other), so if we can lynch scum today, it will make it a whole lot better. Why do you want to wait?

 

[Gaurav_7]

Okay so after noticing. Rebel has been quite when the thread was hot. He's one of the experienced player in Mafia games. So why still Rebel hasn't found FP sus.? Rebel is one of those few who wasn't brought up in the lime light.

FOS: Rebel and FP

Yeah because when the thread was hot, I was at work and was only reading a bit. I am mostly online via mobile when at work so cannot always post.

And for everyone suspecting me because I haven't fosed FP or have agreed with him, I genuinely feel he is a townie trying to find anti town. It is because I too am as confused as he seems to be given the setup. There are essentially 4 anti towns and two town masons who know each other. So more than half of the players while the others like me are trying to still figure out how to play this setup as this is the first time I am playing in this and am sure many others too.

 

[surendar]

@Rebel2k17 - I cannot keep posting here. This is my morning time Friday & I am at work. I can post only when I can.

 

[surendar]

You seriously haven't found anyone "a little sus" yet? If we keep waiting for some clue to magically appear, we'll end up without a lynch, and Mafia and Werewolves will kill two people at night. Two kills are guaranteed (unless they manage to hit each other), so if we can lynch scum today, it will make it a whole lot better. Why do you want to wait?

You can debate the same other way - If you have town lynched by mistake & 2 kills happen on town, it is going to put us in bad situation of loosing 3 & 4 scums making to Day 2.

One thing which I am not finding right after reading last few pages - "If I were mafia, I will do this", "waiting for evidence", "I don't see person as mafia" is not convincing at all @Yash. If you are town, you doubt everyone as mafia trying to find odd man out. If you are mafia, you will wait for evidence to turn someone to look like mafia.

Unable to quote those posts as I am in mobile - but those posts where you were waiting for evidence, you got caught there.

Lynch : Yash