End Game Mafia returns

[Ashutosh.]

His agreement looked more like a joke.

I'm finding Ashutosh. very fishy here, considering he isn't that inexperienced. He was elected to be the backup for CK, at the Mafia Championship this time.

TBH, I did not see this post. You and Z posted at the same time and I opened this page, saw Z's post and went on other thread. After few minutes when RUDI quoted my post, I got an alert. I opened it and posted this message.

Day 1 has passed and it's Day 2 but we have achieved nothing. We all are playing very defensive. If one or two of us will get killed in the night then still we will have nothing to discuss. I can see clear victory of scum with this approach.

 

[RUDI]

It’s better to not make changes on the fly, imo.

I agree with CK. Let it be the same. Since the game started, I feel we don't need to change anything now.

Question to both @CerealKiller and @zwarrior :
When I saw Till Valhalla's post my first reaction was yeah, give me some insight as in how to find scum, but I waited to see other players reactions.

Why didn't you guys hesitate? Why so eager to keep things closed/secret? Or why not discuss it with other players before saying "don't make changes" ?

 

[CerealKiller]

Question to both @CerealKiller and @zwarrior :
When I saw Till Valhalla's post my first reaction was yeah, give me some insight as in how to find scum, but I waited to see other players reactions.

Why didn't you guys hesitate? Why so eager to keep things closed/secret? Or why not discuss it with other players before saying "don't make changes" ?

Personally, i was just saying my view , if i am outnumbered, or Jack feels otherwise, he can do whatever he wants. We began the game with a closed setup, and revealing it after starting takes some fun out of it, in my opinion.

 

[asprin]

at least till he replies

I thought I already did, didn't I?

he answers like an experienced guy. Overcompensating?

Sorry, what part are you referring to?

 

[Till Valhalla]

12 more hours for day 2

 

[zwarrior]

Question to both @CerealKiller and @zwarrior :
When I saw Till Valhalla's post my first reaction was yeah, give me some insight as in how to find scum, but I waited to see other players reactions.

Why didn't you guys hesitate? Why so eager to keep things closed/secret? Or why not discuss it with other players before saying "don't make changes" ?

Simply because if someone starts a game with a certain plan, I don't like to see it getting changed after it starts.

And have I ever said other players not to discuss about it ? Did I tell Jack to go with what I told ? I just stated my opinion. If other players did not talk about it or discuss about it, it is upto them, including you. Because you are bringing this topic today. After 3 days ! Atleast I posted my opinions.

 

[Yash.]

Ashutosh said that he would only reply to our discussions as he is inexperienced and cannot bring up any discussion by himselfI felt it was weird of him to say so considering he has enough experience in Mafia.

Day 1 has passed and it's Day 2 but we have achieved nothing. We all are playing very defensive. If one or two of us will get killed in the night then still we will have nothing to discuss. I can see clear victory of scum with this approach.

After that he replied the above just after my allegation.
@asprin

(The edits in the post were to correct that grammar so the post isn’t misunderstood )

 

[RUDI]

Changed my mind about the possibility of a cop. A role blocker would make more sence.

I am going with this setup unless proven otherwise:

1 x Role blocker
3 x townies

1 x Serial killer
1 x Mafia

 

[Ashutosh.]

After that he replied the above just after my allegation.

TBH, I did not see this post. You and Z posted at the same time and I opened this page, saw Z's post and went on other thread. After few minutes when RUDI quoted my post, I got an alert. I opened it and posted this message.

 

[asprin]

After that he replied the above just after my allegation.

I found that to be common knowledge. In other words, nothing seems to suggest that it was something that people might miss.

Changed my mind about the possibility of a cop.

What made you do that?

 

[RUDI]

I found that to be common knowledge. In other words, nothing seems to suggest that it was something that people might miss.


What made you do that?

With two possible night killers it doesn't make sense to track the murders, but rather to try and stop a murder from happening.

 

[Ashutosh.]

Looks like this game is almost over for me. Either I will get lynched on this day, or I will be killed by mafia/SK in the night on the suspicion of being another mafia/SK.

That's why I was posting less in the beginning and said that I am inexperienced. I wanted to remain alive till last day.

The way Yash framed me was superb. Right now my suspicion is on him.

FOS - Yash

 

[RUDI]

LOL, AK . Why do feel the sudden need to defend yourself?
They were just feeling you out.

 

[Ashutosh.]

Why do feel the sudden need to defend yourself?

Because I want to win.

 

[zwarrior]

With two possible night killers it doesn't make sense to track the murders, but rather to try and stop a murder from happening.

This makes sense if there is a serial killer but we can't be sure of that since the plot which Jack wrote is 'combination of flavour and interpretation.'

Looks like this game is almost over for me. Either I will get lynched on this day, or I will be killed by mafia/SK in the night on the suspicion of being another mafia/SK.

That's why I was posting less in the beginning and said that I am inexperienced. I wanted to remain alive till last day.

The way Yash framed me was superb. Right now my suspicion is on him.

FOS - Yash

You are becoming too defensive now. Everyone wants to be alive till the last day. Posting less to be alive is never a valid argument! You are using 'I am inexperienced' card way too often and seems suspicious to desperately save yourself.

FOS : Ashu