End Game Dethwing Classic Mafia - Town (asprin/CerealKiller) Wins!

[CerealKiller]

So do we go the usual route of revealing our investigation?

Pretty obvious, it's the only way.
Investigated Fake Passport , got Mafia

 

[asprin]

Investigated LBW, got mafia. So my options are:

• Sane
• Insane
• Paranoid

 

[CerealKiller]

Investigated LBW, got mafia. So my options are:

• Sane
• Insane
• Paranoid

Assuming you're telling the truth
CK - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
asprin - Sane/Insane/Paranoid

Need everyone's results

 

[Ashutosh.]

Assuming you're telling the truth
CK - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
asprin - Sane/Insane/Paranoid

Need everyone's results

LBW. - Town Cop

 

[CerealKiller]

LBW. - Town Cop

CK (FP - Mafia) - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
asprin (LBW - Mafia) - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
Ashutosh (LBW - Town) - Sane/Insane/Naive

Still nothing clear. Need @Fake Passport @LBW.

 

[CerealKiller]

@Ashutosh. it's a rule that you shouldn't thank other posts in Mafia, to avoid confusion

 

[RUDI]

Investigated Cerealkiller - result = mafia

 

[CerealKiller]

CK (FP - Mafia) - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
asprin (LBW - Mafia) - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
Ashutosh (LBW - Town) - Naive
LBW (CK - Mafia) - Sane/Insane/Paranoid[DOUBLEPOST=1554496208][/DOUBLEPOST]Need FP's analysis now

 

[RUDI]

Investigated LBW, got mafia. So my options are:

• Sane
• Insane
• Paranoid

Insane or paranoid

LBW. - Town Cop

Sane

^ judging on my role as I know that I am not the goon.
CK - Sane, Insane or paranoid[DOUBLEPOST=1554496364][/DOUBLEPOST]

CK (FP - Mafia) - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
asprin (LBW - Mafia) - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
Ashutosh (LBW - Town) - Naive
LBW (CK - Mafia) - Sane/Insane/Paranoid[DOUBLEPOST=1554496208][/DOUBLEPOST]Need FP's analysis now

AK - or naive
Thanks CK , forgot the naive one.

 

[Fake Passport]

Investigated LBW and got Town.[DOUBLEPOST=1554496992][/DOUBLEPOST]

So do we go the usual route of revealing our investigation?

Yea that's not a red flag at all...

 

[CerealKiller]

CK (FP - Mafia)
asprin (LBW - Mafia)
Ashutosh (LBW - Town)
LBW (CK - Mafia)
FP (LBW - Town)

Assuming CK is Mafia
asprin - Insane
Ashutosh - Sane/Naive
LBW - Paranoid
FP - Sane/Naive
Not cleared

Assuming @asprin is Mafia
CK - Insane/Paranoid
Ashutosh - Sane/Naive
LBW - Insane/Paranoid
FP - Sane/Naive
Not cleared

Assuming Ashutosh is Mafia
CK - Insane/Paranoid
asprin - Insane/Paranoid
LBW - Insane/Paranoid
FP - Sane/Naive
So @Ashutosh. is cleared as town

Assuming @LBW. is Mafia
CK - Paranoid
asprin - Sane
Ashutosh - Insane/Naive
FP - Insane/Naive
Not cleared

Assuming @Fake Passport is Mafia
CK - Sane
asprin - Insane/Paranoid
Ashutosh - Naive
LBW - Insane/Paranoid
Not cleared

 

[Fake Passport]

Thanks for that CK - Saved me a job
That's one problem with Dethy, once the analysis is done its hard to generate discussion and get the mafioso posting.

Ill stick my neck out and start something:
Asprin -Its very easy to tunnel the prolific early poster and tonally Im not sure aspirin posted that from a Mafia POV. Defo not cleared though.
CK - Wanting to extract information out of everyone from a purely analytical perspective. The easy play this early but not an uncommon mafia trick as its information that is going to come out anyway and makes you look active without giving anything away.
LBW -Guilty as always Has a town lean on him

What does everyone else think?

 

[CerealKiller]

Thanks for that CK - Saved me a job
That's one problem with Dethy, once the analysis is done its hard to generate discussion and get the mafioso posting.

Ill stick my neck out and start something:
Asprin -Its very easy to tunnel the prolific early poster and tonally Im not sure aspirin posted that from a Mafia POV. Defo not cleared though.
CK - Wanting to extract information out of everyone from a purely analytical perspective. The easy play this early but not an uncommon mafia trick as its information that is going to come out anyway and makes you look active without giving anything away.
LBW -Guilty as always Has a town lean on him

What does everyone else think?

Something similar could be said about you
Analysing the obvious, trying to look like someone who really wants to help the townies by posting at a time when, in your own words, it's hard to generate discussion.
By saying that it's unusual that the mafia posts at this moment in the game, you're further taking the spotlight away from you. And having posted the result of your investigation after everyone else, you had a clear advantage as well.

So do we go the usual route of revealing our investigation?

What else "route" did you have in mind? Did you want to post your results after someone else did so first?

 

[Fake Passport]

Im more than happy to cop the flack for posting something to get the discussion going. That reply you made gives everyone a chance to get a better read on you

 

[asprin]

So, fingers are being pointed towards me. I guess that's okay. Cannot really fault anyone for trying to pick on anything in sight. Agree with FP - It's the first day so we need something to discuss about.

Yea that's not a red flag at all...

Not surprising to see you jump on this. You're perhaps trying to set the ball rolling, so maybe the explanation below might help.

What else "route" did you have in mind?

So to address CK's concern about the "route", do you really think there is only way of playing this mode? Just off the top of my head, perhaps we could have taken advantage of the restlessness of the mafia guy. It is possible (however small the percentage) that on witnessing insignificant activity, he might lose his patience and slip. I've seen it happen numerous times and wouldn't be surprised to see it happen again.