Well, i have the game....and Id give it 8/10.
Sure, there're a lot of flaws - most of them superficial, so they really dont affect the core gameplay all that much....Batting is an absolute blast - both challenging and fun! There're a lot of nice touches here and there, some good celebrations, player likenesses and the like.....
Id say its probably the best cricket game since BLC - it's as good as that!