ESPN Star is by far the best sports channel in India. But thats because the other ones are pure junk. The ESPN Star commentary panel are highly biased and at times get very irritating. Besides I remember they had included useless programmes like Shaz and Waz, where they had ladies who knew little about the sport live on air along side Ravi Shastri and Wasim Akram. They even had filmstars up there, talking about anything but cricket.
Their stats and analysis are good, but so are that of Ten Sports. Nothing great about that. Sky in the UK and Channel 9 in Australia top the list when it comes to pre,post and ingame analysis with all their latest technologies.
The Commentary team of ESPN Star Sports have some really good names, but are highly biased towards the home side (i.e India). Its only the foreign imports like Boycott and Wilkins who do a decent and unbiased job.
But despite of all these -ve points, they are still the best in India. So I guess I would be very surprised if they did not win the bid to telecast the Indian home matches.
Ten Sports - Good analysis, but still not as lively and interactive as ESPN. Good commentators with an unbiased look to the matches.
Doordarshan - Horrible production team. They do manage to get a few decent commentators, but they really arent good enough to handle any international cricket match.
Sony Max - well probably the worst option. They telecast the ICC competion matches, but have a terrible production team, commentary team, and useless analysis.
Zee - will be their first entry into the world of sports, so cant say anything about them.