End Game Quick n Dirty Dethy Game 1 - Day 1 (Town wins)

[CerealKiller]

Investigated Simon, result says town.

Investigated Simon, result said town.

Investigated Si.. wait
Investigated CerealKiller. Town.

Investigated Jack Ryder, result was Mafia

Villain : Sane/Insane/Naive
asprin : Sane/Insane/Naive
Simon : Sane/Insane/Naive
CK : Sane/Insane/Paranoid

Need JR's investigation

 

[SiriusBlack]

Villain and asprin are the sane and naive cops, assuming they're telling the truth. Ik I'm town so I can safely rule out insane. Since sane and insane are taken, and I can't be paranoid, I am therefore insane, and CK is mafia. Interesting. Let's see what JR has to say. Nothing concrete to go after yet.

 

[Till Valhalla]

Investigated CK got Mafia.[DOUBLEPOST=1503522466][/DOUBLEPOST]Sorry everybody to keep you waiting.

 

[SiriusBlack]

Ok, I'll sort all the players by possibilities and see what we can work out from there.

Sane:

Villain
asprin
Simon or JR
CK

Insane:

Simon or JR
CK

Paranoid:

CK
JR

Naive:

Villain
asprin
Simon

If Villain is mafia,

asprin - sane/naive
Simon - sane/insane/naive
CK - insane/paranoid
JR - insane/paranoid

If asprin is mafia,

Villain - sane/naive
Simon - sane/insane/naive
CK - insane/paranoid
JR - insane/paranoid

If CK is mafia,

Villain - sane/naive
asprin - sane/naive
Simon - insane
JR - paranoid

If JR is mafia,

Villain - sane/naive
asprin - sane/naive
Simon - sane/naive
CK - paranoid

There's no possibility of an insane mafia in this instance, so I can rule out the possibility of JR as mafia, based on the evidence present and assumed true. Need more input to carry discussion forward at this point.

 

[Till Valhalla]

Villain Investigated Simon, result says town.
asprin Investigated Simon, result said town.
Simon Investigated CerealKiller. Town.
Cereal Killer Investigated Jack Ryder, result was Mafia
Jack Ryder Investigated CerealKiller, result was Mafia.

Assuming Villain is Mafia.
Asprin - Sane/Naive
Simon - Sane/Naive
CK - Insane/Paranoid
JR - Insane/Paranoid

Assuming Asprin is mafia(This is the best part).
Villain - Sane/naive
Simon - Sane/Naive
CK - Insane/Paranoid
JR - Insane/Paranoid

Assuming Simon is mafia
Villain - Insane/Naive
Asprin - Insane/Naive
CK - Paranoid
JK - Paranoid
No Sane hence Simon is Town.

Assuming CK is Mafia
Villain - Sane/Naive
Asprin - Sane/Naive
Simon - Insane/Naive
JR - Sane/Paranoid

Assuming JR is mafia.
Villain - Sane/Naive
Asprin - Sane/Naive
Simon - Sane/Naive
CK - Sane/Paranoid
No insane hence JR is Town.

 

[SiriusBlack]

Good progress. We're already down to 3, assuming none of the townies fake claimed. No locked lynches so:

lynch Villain for some pressure.

 

[Till Valhalla]

Good progress. We're already down to 3, assuming none of the townies fake claimed. No locked lynches so:

lynch Villain for some pressure.

Are you on for some time, I think I have a lock on mafia but need to clear up the theory, so when I post the theory you can lynch the guy and we end it on day 1.

 

[Till Valhalla]

Are you on for some time, I think I have a lock on mafia but need to clear up the theory, so when I post the theory you can lynch the guy and we end it on day 1.

Strike that.
Lynch: CerealKiller
Pressure.

 

[Fake Passport]

Mod Note: A reminder that the day is firm. (About 3.5 hours from now, but opening post is the offical timestamp)

No Lynch is an option, but not assumed.
If there is a tie at the end of the day, the lynch will be randomised. ​

 

[Villain]

Sorry for the inactivity lads, was away.

Good progress. We're already down to 3, assuming none of the townies fake claimed. No locked lynches so:

lynch Villain for some pressure.

I did what I had to and posted my results upfront, not something a mafia would do anyway.

 

[Villain]

Mod Note: A reminder that the day is firm. (About 3.5 hours from now, but opening post is the offical timestamp)

No Lynch is an option, but not assumed.
If there is a tie at the end of the day, the lynch will be randomised. ​

Does that mean the one having most votes at the end of the day(even one like the current scenario) will be lynched?

If that's the case;

Lynch: Simon

I'm town, it's better I drag him to my current position(where one of CK/me will be lynched, randomised) than just die being a Cop which is much better since I know my alignment - assuming the one with most votes gets lynched.

 

[Villain]

I'll go through the analysis posted earlier and post mine too, I'm not going to count someone as town for now at least.

 

[asprin]

Just logged in. Will revive the posts shortly.

 

[asprin]

So we have about 50 minutes from the time of this post before the day ends. I think we should hold off on the lynches and decide who is gonna investigate who at night.

From the postings so far,
asprin and Villain investigated the same person
Simon and JR investigated the same person

So how about reversing it during the night?

 

[SiriusBlack]

Lynch: Simon

I'm one of the two people confirmed town using evidence presented right before your eyes. And you're doing this after knowing that a random lynch could have me lynched?
So you're cool with a townie dying as long as it's not you? lol. What kind of town play is that?