End Game Marseille Mafia - The End - The Mimes and the Mafia win (User,Rudi,zwarrior & Jack)

[Na Maloom Afraad]

Oh, boy. AliB had a bad outing.

 

[asprin]

That's an unexpected causality. Ali was nowhere in the target zone as far as I'm concerned. I doubt that this was a mafia kill because Ali dying would have not helped them much.

 

[Gaurav_7]

That's an unexpected causality. Ali was nowhere in the target zone as far as I'm concerned. I doubt that this was a mafia kill because Ali dying would have not helped them much.

That is what I am also thinking. I doubt mafia will have wanted Ali dead tbh.

Oh, boy. AliB had a bad outing.

And why are you sort of happy with that? We lost a townie..

Jack I was just stating what I felt. You got a bit worried, it seems.

 

[Na Maloom Afraad]

And why are you sort of happy with that? We lost a townie..

Not happy, just find it funny. For two reasons.

He targeted two people. One was Me, the other one Jack. I had my suspicion on Jack, but no one supported Me. So, maybe Jack is the one behind it? I find it funny because he had suspicion on Jack and had to pay the price for it straight afterwards. And also, because he had doubts on me. Didn't end well for him.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Point noted

It is upto you how you intend to run it.

Lynch: PEvil

I will stick to my earlier lynch and would like to know what Evil has to say.

 

[zwarrior]

That's an unexpected causality. Ali was nowhere in the target zone as far as I'm concerned. I doubt that this was a mafia kill because Ali dying would have not helped them much.

Why would Vigilante want Ali dead ? Can't rule out mafia so easily.

 

[asprin]

Why would Vigilante want Ali dead ?

Of course he wouldn't. I may be wrong here but I think a town vigilante wouldn't know who his allies are too, just like a vanilla townie. Hence the deduction that it might have been a blind kill.

 

[Targaryen]

Unfortunate to lose Ali as he wasn't too suspicious. I'm suspecting User2010 here. He has given a reason of inactivity on Day 1 for lynching me and when I posted, he wants me to 'say'.

FoS: User2010

 

[RUDI]

"As the sun rose, the Townies were horrified to find a dead body lying in the street. It was AliB, a Vanilla Townie"

Not a good for us at all

Jailkeeper did a good job. He definitely blocked a mafia or vigilante. Or he could have blocked someone and that person might have been targeted by mafia/vigilante. So, mafias/vigilante and jailkeeper has good information right now. Definitely jail keeper would get more information on 2nd night and that character is the most important one..

Note that CK did not mention whether Ali was killed by mafia or vigilante.

That's interesting as only person Ali was sus of is Jack. Also there being only one kill means either of vig or mafia failed with theirs so maybe the jailkeeper was at play here.

I was surprised how people went for no lynch very quickly after I lynched Evil. His replies when Rudolph too lynched him seemed suspicious to me. But when I logged back, it was already night. Also I would have hoped the writeup gave us some hints at least.

• 1 Town Jailkeeper

• 1 Town Compulsive Vigilante

Ali was surprisingly not that active, suppose he tried to stay under the radar for as long as possible. Why would the Mafia kill someone who wasn't a thread? Even if he was a mime the Mafia can still win if he is around.
That brings us to option number two : The compulsive vigilante - What a waste of a one shot (isn't that he only get one shot? ) Must be you considered Ali's silence as a possible Mafia sign, you could have waited at least a bit before wasting the shot
Is the Jailkeeper role similar to that of a doctor?

 

[Perfect Square]

We lost a valuable member. Even though Ali was a Vanilla Townie, but still he was a townie.

I still doubt on even Jack. Even though I went with no lynch seeing that everyone was going with no lynch and it was Day 1 and my vote wouldn't have done any difference. Though he defended himself well. But I am still doubtful on Jack.

I don't have doubt on anyone else yet. So I'm Fosing Jack, until I get doubt on anyone else.

Is the Jailkeeper role similar to that of a doctor?

Yes

 

[zwarrior]

"As the sun rose, the Townies were horrified to find a dead body lying in the street. It was AliB, a Vanilla Townie"

Not a good for us at all




Ali was surprisingly not that active, suppose he tried to stay under the radar for as long as possible. Why would the Mafia kill someone who wasn't a thread? Even if he was a mime the Mafia can still win if he is around.
That brings us to option number two : The compulsive vigilante - What a waste of a one shot (isn't that he only get one shot? ) Must be you considered Ali's silence as a possible Mafia sign, you could have waited at least a bit before wasting the shot
Is the Jailkeeper role similar to that of a doctor?

No. Vigilante is not one shot. He should kill every night.

 

[CerealKiller]

@RUDOLPH click on "Setup" on the first page to get info on the roles.

 

[zwarrior]

It is upto you how you intend to run it.

Lynch: PEvil

I will stick to my earlier lynch and would like to know what Evil has to say.

Why did you vote for Sodium ? Is it just for creating pressure or any genuine reason ?

I don't have any logical reason behind my suspicions. But my FOS is on Gaurav and a little bit of Jack and Asprin. Just a gut feeling.

What I feel is, atleast one of the mafia is experienced player. He is trying to create confusion by killing Ali. I know it's not certain that a mafia would have killed Ali, but just revealing my thoughts.

 

[Na Maloom Afraad]

I agree, one of the Mafia seems to be an experienced player. AliB's death has confused us.

 

[Perfect Square]

No. Vigilante is not one shot. He should kill every night.

How are you too sure? Vigilante could be one shot or 3 shots.

You were super worried about Ali. in this post. As if you killed Ali. But you could be Vigilante or Mafia.

But as @RUDOLPH said Jailkeeper could've jailed Mafia and Vigilante just random shoot anyone.

You're post can be about that you didn't want a townie to be killed by me and as if you know its difficult to kill a mafia.

But like NMA and You said the Mafia has confused us and from my gut feeling I think you're a Vigilante. And if you're a Vigilante then surely Mafia was in Jail and you killed Ali.

Why would Vigilante want Ali dead ? Can't rule out mafia so easily.